|
||||||||||
Let's get a grip on how much water we're talking about. The volume of the bore is somewhere around 150 cubic centimeters. One cc of water weighs one gram, your flute is missing 250 grams of water, more than enough water to fill the bore--nearly twice. Now you know why flutes crack. Moisture content (MC) is a little bit like talking about exerting 110% in terms of effort/commitment/etc. To calculate MC, divide the moisture weight by the dry wood weight and multiply by 100 ( (M/W) x 100 ). So green bamboo often has a moisture content well over 100%. Moisture in bamboo is divided into two parts: free water and bound water. Think of a wet sponge. You can squeeze out the free water but the sponge remains moist with the bound water. Something called the fiber saturation point (FSP) identifies the point between free and bound water, which in bamboo runs around 20%. As bamboo dries the free water leaves first and the MC drops to 20%, at which point the bound water begins evaporating. An important point to remember is that dimensional changes (shrinking/swelling/cracking/etc.) only occur as bound water is lost or gained. Placing dried bamboo in 100% humidity indefinitely will only raise the MC to 20%. Once the bound water is replenished bamboo stops absorbing moisture from the air. To replenish free water the culm needs to be submerged. Bound water is held in the cellular walls in molecular form by forces of attraction, free water fills the cell cavities. Bound water is directly involved in the structure of bamboo, free water is just along for the ride. The hydration graph below plots bound water versus humidity. All the moisture action you need be concerned with (in regards to a bamboo flute cracking) is contained in the graph--it's all about the bound water. To be clear, the graph (below 20% MC) only becomes operational after all free water has left the culm. Shrinkage doesn't begin until bound water starts evaporating. The graph indicates the moisture content of your flute probably never rises much above 10-12%. Note also that varying the relative humidity surrounding your flute from 40% to 60% results is just a few percent change in the moisture content of the flute. 50% humidity (6% MC) is usually considered the minimum to remain crack free. Bamboo fishing rod makers need to keep the MC above a certain level in order for the glue to set and work right. Otherwise, the fishing rods start coming apart latter. For those particularly interested in the MC of their flutes, weighing a flute is probably the simplest and most accurate way to determine water gain and loss.
Here are two links with current US relative humidity: National Humidity and Regional Map. Throughout the long history of the craft of Japanese flute-making one fact has remained true: bamboo is a poor material choice for flutes. Bamboo can't stand up to the demands placed on it by the rigors of flute playing, the material is too fragile and it cracks. Being a very linear material, only in a single direction is it strong and resilient. Radially (across grain), bamboo is virtually without merit. Which is a long way of saying it cracks. At what MC a particular piece of bamboo may crack is dependent on many factors, chief among them, age/development of the wood structure and wall thickness--thicker walls being more prone to cracking. But for many flutes there is some point of moisture content where the stress becomes too great and the wall ruptures. If the MC of your flute is under 20% it is experiencing some degree of stress. Samples are all from the same piece of bamboo.
If you were to band-saw a section from your flute right now and split it, it would spring open in the manner of the left sample above--indicating the amount of stress it was under. This desire to crack is perpetual and will reside in your flute as long as it exists. As can be deduced from the center sample, the stress level in your flute is directly related to its degree of hydration. When a hydrated sample (right) is left to dry the stress returns. We've taken bamboo dried to less than 5%, immersed it until the MC is above 20% and dried again, to demonstrate the absorption/desorpsion cycle. It also becomes obvious that the blond color associated with bamboo is largely the result of empty cells cavities filled with air. There's a difference between the inner and outer portions of the bamboo wall and more of the vascular bundles (the water/sap carriers) are in the outer wall. Thus, as bamboo dries and the bound water evaporates, the outer wall shrinks proportionally more than the inner, creating stress which, if it becomes great enough, will lead to wall rupture and a crack. In simple terms, the bamboo cell wall is a composite made of a rigid cellulose polymer in a matrix of lignin and the hemicelluloses. The lignin polymer is thermoplastic; that is, it softens upon heating. The glass transition temperature Tg of the lignin in the matrix is approximately 170C (338F). Above the matrix Tg, it is possible to cause the lignin to undergo thermoplastic flow and, upon cooling, reset in the same or modified configuration. This is the principal behind bending bamboo with heat.The strength of bamboo is virtually unchanged while free water is leaving the culm. But once the free water is gone and bound water starts evaporating the values for strength, hardness, and stiffness begin rising and culminate at zero moisture content after having risen substantially. Oven dried bamboo is at it strongest with relation to moisture. Surprisingly, even greater strengths can be obtained by lowering the temperature. Dropped well below freezing the strength of bamboo continues to rise. Speaking of temperature in general, the strength of bamboo falls as the temperature rises--about 5% for every 10F rise. So, placing your flute in a hot car such that the temperature goes from 70 to 100 degrees drops the strength about 15%. If the flute is under stress anyway, elevated temperatures could cause it to crack. In the shakuhachi world there's a lot of talk about CURED bamboo. Curing is just a fancy word for drying. Expelling the free water can happen in weeks, if not days. Once the MC gets down to 20%, evaporation should be slowed a bit and dropped to 10% in a few months. Then the culm is dry-- it's cured, it's done. Nothing further is going to happen, even if it sits around for twenty years following the seasonal variations in humidity. The sponge by the kitchen sink doesn't 'cure', it just dries. In short, letting bamboo sit around for years doesn't facilitate any process which has any relevance to flute making. No time-dependent transformative process takes place--chemical, spiritual or otherwise. 'Curing' is simply drying green bamboo. CURED bamboo is a sales gimmick, about all it means is the bamboo is probably covered with dust. Once the free water is gone bamboo begins shrinking in diameter as much as 10-16% as well as in wall thickness (15-17%). Such shrinkage is appreciably higher than encountered in wood. Which brings us to another myth. Since there is little dimensional change during free water absorption/desorpsion, it doesn't matter a whole lot how much free water bamboo contains. So it shouldn't make much difference when bamboo for flutes is cut. Water levels could be quite high, MC approaching 150%, but since free water has little to do with anything flute-wise it shouldn't matter. The tradition of cutting flute culms in the fall isn't a water issue, as many suppose, but a starch issue. Dry season is the best time to harvest bamboo when the culms are lowest in terms of starch content level making it less susceptible to powder post beetle attack. No shoot emergence also occurs during this time, hence shoot damage is evaded. In some areas of Japan, bamboo harvest is signaled by the yearly appearance of Pleiades (Subaru in Japanese) at dusk--around the first of November. Another thing to realize. Since dimensional variations only takes place during bound water gain/loss, any time the MC of your flute changes, it's bore diameter and wall thickness also change. What this means is the sound of your flute is dependent on it's moisture content. And you thought the shakuhachi was simple! The difference between your 1.8 jinashi shak being at the Fiber Saturation Point and zero Moisture Content would be an average of 13% difference in bore diameter, which is about 3.5 EAR points. So with the normal variations in your flute's MC you can expect a one point shift in EAR. What does your flute sound like? It really depends on it's moisture content--which changes. This fact calls into question the comparison of different flute's timbre when moisture contents aren't known AND the MC at which each flute is intended to sound it's best isn't known. Any high-level pronouncement about ultra-refined tonal variation, made without knowledge of moisture content, should be treated with caution.
|